
Is new pinball better or do we just love new toys?
We pulled 18 years of the Pinside Top 100 from the Wayback Machine and compared it with Pinball Ranker. The short answer is that people mostly just love new shiny toys. Once a game stops being new it slides, and former top games now sit below many games they used to beat.

Nick C
It’s a running joke in the pinball community that the Pinside Top 100 is just a list of whatever came out last. Like moths to a flame, we all still go and look at it anyway. For this post, we dug up 18 years’ worth of Top 100 data using the Wayback Machine, just to see if the blatant recency bias has always been a thing. The short answer is that people mostly just love new shiny toys. Once a game stops being new it slides, and we show below that former top games now sit below many games they used to beat.
First, here is Pinside’s top 10 at the time of writing next to the top 10 on Pinball Ranker. Pinside generates its leaderboard by asking its users to rate various elements of a game, which are then combined to make its overall score per game for ranking. Pinball Ranker is a newer site that shows you two games and asks which one you would rather play. Through thousands of A/B comparisons, a leaderboard emerges.
We added some lines between the lists to make it obvious which games make the top 10 in both lists.
Pinside’s top 10 is mostly stuff from the last few years. Ranker’s is mostly 90s Williams and Bally. Harry Potter is #2 on Pinside and #155 on Ranker. That isn’t for lack of votes either, as it has come up in over 5,000 head-to-heads on Ranker.
Pinside Top 100 history from the Wayback Machine
Pinside only shows the current list, so you can’t look back at how it has changed. The Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine has been saving copies of web pages since the 90s, and it has saved the Pinside Top 100 page 285 times since 2008.
Each column adds up to all 100 games on the list, like a pie chart laid on its side. From 2008 to about 2018 the list only changed subtly, with 90s games holding around 60 of the 100 places. From 2020 the newer games took over quickly. Games from the 2020s went from 3 places to 40 in six years, and in 2025 they passed the 90s games.
To be fair, some of that is just how it should be. New games come out every year and some of them are properly good, so the list has to make room for them. It doesn’t happen for everything though. Look at the thin green band. That’s the 2000s, pinball’s dark era, when Stern was pretty much the only one left making games. Even in 2008, when those games were still new, they only had 15 places.
The bar on the right is Pinball Ranker’s top 100 today. It still has 33 games from the 90s and 31 from before 1990, and only 19 from the 2020s. That doesn’t automatically make Ranker the honest one though. A lot of its crowd might be operating in conscious or subconscious rebellion against the new shiny stuff dominating the Pinside top 100! Both lists have their own lean.
The scores themselves have crept up too. Twilight Zone was #1 in 2008, and the score it had then would only put it 5th today.
The fall from grace
This is where some games that made it to the top spot ended up in the years after. Tron, TNA and Mando (somehow) all reached pole position and have since plummeted. Total Nuclear Annihilation got to #1 on 15 ratings, which was the bare minimum to be on the list at all back then. You could argue they were just pushed down by better new games, and some of them were. But The Mandalorian is now #81, and 50 of the 80 games above it were already on the list, below it, the year it was top. Total Nuclear Annihilation has dropped below 32 games it used to beat, and TRON below 17. Those games didn’t get any better in the meantime. The only thing that changed is that the top-spot title stopped being new. Godzilla has been #1 in every copy since 2022 and is in Ranker’s top 10 too, so it might actually just be that good*.
* We're well aware that GZ was toppled from the throne recently before jumping back to top spot, but our snapshot timing missed that brief glitch in the matrix.
Pinside vs Pinball Ranker
Pinside’s list is a good guide to what community members are excited about at the moment. For a list of which games people would rather play, Pinball Ranker seemingly does a better job (or at least it aligns more closely with this author’s internal bias 😛), so that is what we use for the ratings on individual Pinq pages, and to give context to career charts on such pages as Pat Lawlor and Kevin O’Connor etc. Pinball Ranker only started in May 2026, so give it time and it may well start showing recency bias. We’ll be back with the Wayback Machine to check.
Pinside data is from 33 Wayback Machine copies of pinside.com/pinball/top-100, December 2008 to October 2026. Pinside lists each game once, scored on its best rated edition. Pinball Ranker data is its solid state list on 16 November 2026.
Share this post
Like this post? Share it with your friends!